User:JohnD'Alembert/sandbox/archive:allegoryPlato
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Allegorical Interpretations of Plato
Hi, I’m a UK academic specializing in ancient Greek philosophy and do the occasional Wikipedia page. I was translating the article on the Pseudo-Platonic Horoi from the German Wikipedia, and noticed in the Plato Series Box that the English Wikipedia has several good articles on Plato’s famous allegories but no article on the long and important history of their interpretation, which has been an active area of scholarship for much of the last century. Herewith an outline treatment of that history with references to important scholarly works. Translations from the Greek are my own unless otherwise noted. Please feel free, of course, to make improvements!
Allegorical interpretations of Plato were dominant for more than fifteen hundred years, from about the first century CE through the Renaissance and into the Eighteenth Century. Followers of Plato such as Plotinus, Proclus, and Ficino generally claimed that Plato inserted symbols within his dialogues to give his narratives layers of figurative as well as literal meaning. Beginning with Philo of Alexandria (1st c. CE), these views influenced Jewish, Christian and Islamic interpretation of their holy scriptures. Allegorical interpretations of Plato spread widely in the Renaissance and contributed to the fashion for allegory among poets such as Dante, Spenser, and Shakespeare.[1]
In the early modern period, classical scholarship rejected claims that Plato was an allegorist. After this rupture, the ancient followers of Plato who read the dialogues as sustained allegories were labelled 'Neo-Platonists' and regarded as an aberration. In the wake of Tate's pioneering 1929 article 'Plato and Allegorical Interpretation,'[2] scholars began to study the allegorical approach to Plato in its own right both as essential background to Plato studies and as an important episode in the history of philosophy, literary criticism, hermeneutics, and literary symbolism. Historians have come to reject any simple division between Platonism and Neo-Platonism, and the tradition of reading Plato allegorically is now an area of active research.[3]
The definitions of 'allegory,' 'symbolism,' and 'figurative meaning' evolved over time. The word 'allegory' (Greek for 'saying other') became more frequent in the early centuries CE and referred to language that had some other meaning in addition to its usual or literal meaning. Earlier in classical Athens, it was common instead to speak of 'undermeanings' (Gk., hyponoiai), which referred to hidden or deeper meanings.[4] Today, allegory is often said to be a sustained sequence of metaphors within a literary work, but this was not clearly the ancient definition since then a single passage or even a name could be allegorical. Generally, the changing meanings of such terms must be studied within each historical context.[5]